A Thoughtful Guide to Planning a Marriage Proposal
Choosing a Proposal That Feels Like You Both
​
So you are thinking of popping the question! You and your partner have talked about where life is headed, what you want to build together, and how your futures intersect. If you are planning a proposal, particularly during this season when Valentine’s Day puts romance on the calendar, it helps to think through a few practical and emotional details before worrying about locations or logistics. A little preparation allows the moment to unfold naturally, without tipping anyone off or rushing what should feel unhurried.
​
As a photographer, proposals are one of my favorite moments to document. There is something uniquely human about them: the effort to keep a secret, the nerves disguised as enthusiasm for a walk or a view, and the split second when anticipation turns into something real. My role is to stay out of the way while making sure the moment is preserved, which requires patience, observation, and a willingness to look like just another tourist with a camera.
Start With Alignment, Not the Ring
​
Before you plan anything, make sure you and your partner are genuinely aligned on marriage and the future. This may seem obvious, but it is the most important part. It also helps to think about your story together. Consider:
-
How you spend time together
-
What feels familiar and grounding
-
What kind of life you imagine building side by side
Those answers tend to shape a meaningful proposal speech far more reliably than any dramatic backdrop.
Some people also choose to speak with parents beforehand. For some families, this feels respectful and important. For others, it feels unnecessary or even intrusive. There is no universal rule here, only the value of understanding the family dynamics you are stepping into.
Plan the Moment Without Giving Away the Surprise
​
Once the ring enters the picture, logistics matter more than romance blogs will admit.
​
Solve the Ring size early.
If it is not meant to be a surprise, ask. If it is, borrow a ring they already wear and see how it fits on your finger, or quietly enlist a trusted friend.
​
From the moment you have the ring, keep it safe.
Insure it. Decide where it will live until the proposal. If you are traveling, always carry it with you and never check it. {Some people even tape a small note to the box indicating that it contains an engagement ring, in case of airport security screening.}
​
Suspicion is often the hardest part.
Trips, fancy dinners, or sudden enthusiasm for scenic walks can raise eyebrows. A believable backstory helps. A simple, plausible plan keeps your partner from spending the day wondering why something feels “off.”
​
Flexibility matters more than timing.
If the light is beautiful but the moment does not feel right yet, wait! Proposals do not benefit from being rushed simply because a reservation is approaching or the sun is sinking.
​
Practice the physical details in advance.
Practice your speech first and foremost, practice the kneel if you intend to, and open the ring box a few times so you know how it works. Make a small mark on the bottom so you do not open it upside down. This sounds trivial, but nerves make even simple mechanics feel complicated.
​
Outfits matter.
Choose clothing you feel comfortable in and can move easily in. Constant adjusting, tugging at pockets, or checking for the ring box can draw attention faster than you realize.
​
Common ways to hide the ring box include:
-
Deep coat pockets
-
Backpacks for hikes
-
Socks with the right pants
-
Picnic baskets or tote bags
The best hiding place is the one that fits the plan naturally and lets you forget about it until the moment arrives.
Choose a Place That You Will Look Back on Fondly
​
The strongest proposals usually happen during activities couples already enjoy together, in places that naturally invite a pause. What that pause looks like, however, varies widely.
​
I have photographed proposals that unfolded quietly on morning walks, and others that were planned as full productions. Once, in Union Square, a couple coordinated music, timing, and friends hidden just out of view, ready to appear at the right moment. The plaza became a stage. It worked because both people loved theater, attention, and the shared energy of a crowd. The public nature of it felt celebratory, not overwhelming.
​
Just as often, proposals succeed because no one else knows they are happening at all. This is where the San Francisco Bay Area offers remarkable flexibility.
Some couples gravitate toward places they know they will want to return to such as a trail or stretch of beach that can become an anniversary walk, or a café that is fun to return to again and again, or a bench that invites an annual picnic to remember the proposal moment and reflect. Others want the option of celebration nearby, so a private proposal followed by dinner with friends or family is a memory-creating option.
​
What matters most is not whether a proposal is public or private, scenic or urban, but whether the setting supports who you are together.
​
Marin County is particularly well suited for making meaningful time together. Trails that open onto waterfalls, bluffs overlooking the bay, and beaches with wide horizons create pauses in movement, where people stop naturally, often to remark on the beauty. Sausalito offers pockets with open shade and views toward Angel Island, where the city remains visible across the water but does not dominate the experience. Towns such as Fairfax, San Anselmo, and Larkspur, with walkable streets and stunning redwoods, give a sense of everyday life that feels genuine rather than staged.
​
Hikes tend to work best when they end somewhere that allows for improvisation. Stinson Beach trails are a great place for time together to flow naturally. Plus, knowing there is a café or small hotel nearby takes pressure off the proposal itself and provides options for casual activities before or after a stroll or hike.
​
Do not overlook water as an option.
Proposals on boats, ferries, or even kayaks often feel intimate because the outside world recedes and there is nowhere else to be. Just be careful with that ring!
​
In San Francisco itself, places with built-in views can work well:
-
A walk near the water by the Bay Bridge
-
The view from Twin Peaks across the city
-
The tunnel tops in the Presidio, looking out over the GG Bridge
-
The grounds at the Legion of Honor
The East Bay offers gardens and paths in and around Berkeley, such as the UC Botanical Garden, that lend themselves to wandering conversation. On the coast, the bluffs in Pacifica or the beach below the Ritz-Carlton in Half Moon Bay create space, privacy, and beautiful natural surroundings.
How I Photograph Proposals Without Interrupting Them
​
Almost all of the proposals I photograph are secret. I dress and move like another visitor (just one with a larger camera than most). Sometimes I bring a decoy with me and photograph over their shoulder, adjusting my position slowly so nothing feels abrupt.
Timing is the most challenging part.
Light in the Bay Area is unpredictable, and human nerves even more so. I stay ready, close enough to photograph clearly, far enough away to keep the moment intact.
​
If you are using a photographer, a few small details matter:
-
If your partner has long hair and it is down, gently tucking it behind an ear can help keep their face visible, if it feels natural
-
Staying on one knee until the ring is actually on their finger gives the moment time to land and helps preserve it visually
-
Giving them a few seconds afterward matters as well. Many people cry, laugh, and momentarily forget what just happened
I have heard from many couples that those first seconds feel like a blur because the emotion can be overwhelming. Photographs often become the way those moments come back into focus later, and they tend to become treasured keepsakes shared with family and friends over time.
​
​
A Few Common Proposal Questions- FAQs
​
Is it better to propose publicly or privately?
There is no right answer. Public proposals work best when both people enjoy attention and shared energy. Private proposals tend to feel more intimate and personal. The key is choosing what suits your partner, not what looks impressive.
​
Should I hire a photographer for a proposal?
If photographs matter to you, hiring someone experienced with proposals can help preserve the moment without interrupting it. A discreet approach keeps the surprise intact while documenting reactions that often pass in a blur.
​
What happens if the timing or weather does not cooperate?
Flexibility matters more than perfect conditions. Some of the most meaningful proposals happen when plans shift slightly and the moment arrives naturally.
​
Can proposals work well for LGBTQ+ couples?
Absolutely. Proposals should reflect the people involved, not a script. The same principles apply: alignment, intention, and choosing a setting that feels supportive and affirming.
​​
​
A Final Thought to Carry With You for Planning Your Proposal
​
The most successful proposals are not the most elaborate, they are the most attentive and they reflect how a couple already moves through the world. If you are planning a proposal, especially during this season, choose something that feels like you, and leave space for the moment to arrive naturally.
​
​Read on-->
Wine Country Proposal Locations
Engagement & Proposal Services
​
